Changes at "Items/dimensions: Expected outcomes, social impact and ethical considerations"

FAIL (D)

The expected benefits or outcomes of the research are not mentioned or are not consistent with the research design and objectives.

Ethical considerations and expectations about social impact are not included.

FAIR (C)

The expected benefits or outcomes of the research are briefly mentioned, as are their practical or social implications, but only in broad terms.

Some ethical considerations and principles that guide the research design and future research are presented, but are not fully developed or explained. The Ethics Committee's ethical protocol or the self-assessment form has been completed and the review request proof is submitted.

GOOD (B)

The expected benefits or outcomes of the research and their specific contribution to the field of knowledge are explained, as are their practical or social implications.

The expected return (impact or effect) to society of the results or products of the research is described, but in a rather vague way.

Ethical considerations and principles that guide the research design and future research are presented. These considerations include practices such as voluntary participation, informed consent, anonymity, confidentiality, potential for harm, and communication of results to participants. The Ethics Committee's ethical protocol or the self-assessment form has been completed and the review request proof is submitted.

EXCELLENT (A)

The expected benefits or outcomes of the research and their specific contribution to the field of knowledge are explained, as well as their practical or social implications.

The expected return (impact or effect) to society of the results or products of the research is described, as are the conditions required for its sustainability.

Ethical considerations and principles that guide the research design and future research are presented and discussed. These considerations include practices such as voluntary participation, informed consent, anonymity, confidentiality, potential for harm, and communication of results to participants, as well as other potential ethical implications directly related to the research topic. The Ethics Committee's ethical protocol or the self-assessment form has been completed and the review request proof is submitted.

Weighting

10%

Open Comments

(Write here your comments or suggestions)